| 1958 | High School Player of the Week | Washington Post |
| 1960 | All Metropolitan Team of High School Players | |
| 1960 | Outstanding Football Player of the Year | |
| 1962 | All Atlantic Coast Conference Fullback | Duke University |
| 1963 | Academic All Atlantic Coast Conference | Duke University |
| 1964 | All Atlantic Coast Conference Fullback | Duke University |
| 1964 | Carmen Falcone Team MVP Award | Duke University |
| 1964 | All American - Third Team (FB) | Duke University |
| 1964 | All Time Letterman 1962; 1963; 1964 | Duke University |
| 1968 | All Pro - Pro Bowl | |
| 1969 | NFL - West All Star Team | The Sporting News |
| 1969 | Second Team NEA | |
| 1970 | AFC Outstanding Defensive Player | Kansas City 101 Club |
| 1970 | All Pro - Pro Bowl | |
| 1971 | Team Captain | Baltimore |
| 1971 | All Pro - Pro Bowl | |
| 1971 | AFC Defensive Player of the Week | Associated Press |
| 1971 | Super Bowl V - MVP | New York Chapter of Professional Football Writers of America |
| 1972 | AFC Defensive Player of the Week | New York Chapter of Professional Football Writers of America |
| 1974 | Team Captain | Baltimore |
| 1974 | MVP | Baltimore |
| 1974 | All Pro - Pro Bowl | |
| 1976 | Team Captain | Seattle |
| 1981 | Duke Sports Hall Of Fame | Duke |
Wednesday, January 23, 2008 1:50 PM ToriVi Creations